Challenging Dogma - Spring 2009

Thursday, May 14, 2009

Winning the War against STIs: Why Public Health Interventions have failed to reduce STI rates among Adolescents- Oluwakemi Olukoya

Sexually transmitted diseases (STDs) remain a major public health problem in the United States. The CDC estimates that approximately 19 million new infections occur each year and almost half of the infections occur among young people 15-24 years of age. Though several public health campaigns have been conducted to curb the spread of sexually transmitted diseases (STD) among adolescents, the rate of STDs continues to soar. The failure of these campaigns can be linked to their reliance on traditional health behavior models which have limited ability to change behavior. The traditional health models are limited by their individualistic approach to change behaviors and by their assumption that individuals have mastery and control over decision making and behavior change.

An example of a public health campaign which is based on traditional health behavior models is the It’s Your (Sex) Life (IYSL) national campaign. IYSL is an ongoing partnership of MTV and the Kaiser Family Foundation to help young people make responsible decisions about their sexual health (1). IYSL campaign has distinguished itself from other public health campaigns by winning the Emmy and Peabody award for public information campaign on HIV/AIDS, other sexually transmitted diseases and related sexual health issues. In addition, the recent extension of IYSL partnership with Planned Parenthood Federation of America to promote the GYT (Get Yourself Tested) campaign- aimed at removing the taboos surrounding STD testing- through celebrities seems promising. Despite the above strengths of the IYSL campaign, its’ message, based on traditional health behavior change models (Health Belief Model and Social Learning Theory), has limited ability to change adolescents risky sexual behaviors to preventive behaviors. This article critically reviews the It’s Your (Sex) Life national campaign and presents three arguments which explain the limitations of the IYSL from the perspective of social and behavioral sciences.

I.) Health Belief Model
By using the Health Belief Model, It’s Your (Sex) Life campaign presumes that by promoting ads which emphasize on the consequences and statistics of sexually transmitted diseases, an individual will perceive his susceptibility to acquiring STD and perceive the severity of STD on his life; thus he would rationally weigh the benefits of not engaging in risky sexual behaviors to barriers which leads to intention and safe sex practices. For example, one ad featured a lady instructing a “teenage girl” to break up immediately with her boyfriend who refused to use a condom because she is at risk of contracting HIV.

Though the ad provides factual information, studies have shown that early prevention efforts that involved providing factual information about HIV/AIDS to promote safer sexual practices among adolescents and young adults were not strongly correlated with preventive behaviors(2). Thus, knowledge is necessary but not sufficient for HIV/AIDS risk reduction (2; 3). In addition, findings from various studies(4) that applied the HBM to promote preventive sexual behaviors among heterosexual college students have been inconsistent and provided only partial support for the model. Overall, perceived barriers (to condom use) received the most consistent support as a significant predictor of engaging in preventive behaviors (5). The fact that the extension components of the HBM did not significantly increase the prediction of condom use among college students may reflect the limitations of the HBM in promoting protective behaviors (5).

Furthermore, there is a wider social context within which individuals must circulate such as families and communities, which in turn affect the individuals’ decisions and behavior. HBM does not account for such social and environmental factors. (6) The HBM focus on individual-level factors and its’ reliance on the individual’s ability to make rational decisions and develop intention (7) to engage in protective behaviors constitute a major weakness of this approach. Intention does not always lead to behavior and human actions are mostly irrational. Also, HBM does not take into account the spontaneous activity that characterizes much of human behavior (7)

II.) Self-efficacy versus Self-control
IYSL draws from SLT by promoting self-efficacy. The IYSL campaign assumes that by instructing adolescents to take charge of their sex life by being in control and making smart choices, adolescents will be empowered and thus develop self-efficacy to practice safer sex. However, this assumption is false because individuals lack self-control over their actions due to other influences.

Studies indicate that patterns of social cognitive development in adolescence vary as a function of the content under consideration and the emotional and social context in which the reasoning occurs (8). Adolescents’ reasoning about real-life problems is not as advanced as their reasoning about hypothetical dilemmas (9) (e.g. a female practicing negotiation of condom use in a non-aroused state versus an aroused state). Adolescents’ when faced with a logical argument are more likely to accept faulty reasoning or shaky evidence when they agree with the substance of the argument than when they do not. (10-11). In other words, adolescents’ social reasoning, like that of adults, is influenced not only by their basic intellectual abilities, but by their desires, motives and interests (12).

Behavioral data have made it appear as though adolescents are poor decision-makers (i.e. their high-rates of participation in dangerous activities, automobile accidents, drug use and unprotected sex) however, there is substantial evidence that adolescents engage in dangerous activities despite knowing and understanding the risks involved (13-15). Thus, in real-life situations, adolescents do not simply rationally weigh the relative risks and consequences of their behavior – their actions are largely influenced by feelings and social influences (16). In addition, research has shown that sexual motivation can distort judgments on the risk of contracting sexually transmitted disease (17). Results from a study suggests that arousal does not change an individual’s general knowledge about the risks of unprotected sex, but when it comes to concrete steps involving condoms, sexual arousal changes one’s perceptions of the tradeoffs between benefits and disadvantages in a fashion that decreases the tendency to use them. (18)

III.) Social Determinants
IYSL campaign fails to account for diverse array of factors influencing adolescents’ risk taking behavior (Figure 1). Such factors include familial characteristics such as parental support, peer influence, school environment, community, socioeconomic status, racial disparities and societal factors such as media exposure (19). IYSL campaign may have no influence on adolescents who do not belong to a stable and supportive family system. Families provide role models, shape sexual attitudes, set standards for sexual conduct, control and monitor adolescents’ behaviors. Parental monitoring is associated with older ages of sexual initiation, smaller numbers of sexual partners and more consistent contraceptive use, all of which suggest lower STD risk (20). Thus how will the IYSL campaign account for teenagers, particularly homeless teens, who do not have family support and are predisposed to engage in risky behaviors?

In addition, though IYSL campaign used teenagers to promote its’ message to other teens, the campaign failed to recognize the power of group dynamics in shaping an adolescent decision with regards to which norms to abide to. Peer norms surrounding sexual behaviors and condom use have been shown to be major influences on both risky and protective sexual behavior. When adolescents perceive that friends and similar-aged teens engage in risky sexual behavior, even if their perception is skewed, then they are more likely to adopt those same behaviors (19). IYSL campaign needs to be more strategic in using teenagers in its’ ads in promoting safe sex practices rather than showing teenagers who are willing to adopt condom use because of the consequences of acquiring STDs.

The IYSL campaign failed to take full advantage of the effect of school environment on sexual risk taking behaviors. In one ad, a Professor told a group students that “there is hardly any healthy sexual relations…… they should learn to stop and have a conversation” about sex. Through this ad, IYSL campaign assumes that students have self-control and schools are a good place to let adolescents know they can take charge of their sex life. Though schools play a vital role in sex education, how does IYSL account for other aspects of school social environment associated with risky sexual behaviors? School structural attributes affect norms and attitudes about dating practices and sexual behaviors (21). Studies of the effects of school characteristics on sexual risk-taking behaviors found that racial composition and school type (public or private) are associated with age at first intercourse and number of sexual partners (22). Compared to private schools, teenagers in public schools have a higher STD risk. (21-22).

In addition, IYSL campaign failed to take into consideration racial differences in an ad which lead to counterproductive responses from adolescents. In the commercial, a white teenage girl refused to have sex with a black teenage boy because he did not have a condom to use. Though the ad was trying to tell adolescent females to be firm in their decision of practicing safe sex, the public interpreted it as her being a racist as illustrated by several comments on You Tube. This commercial also failed to use effective communication principles by ensuring a similar group was used as the source of message to the receiving group. The media plays a significant role in socialization of adolescents and therefore impacts their sexual risk and protective behavior. For example, studies have found that greater exposure to rap music videos and X-rated movies were associated with having multiple sex partners, more frequent sexual intercourse, and testing positive for an STD (23, 24). It is ironic that MTV, partners of IYSL campaign, hopes to promote protective sexual behaviors while they show more of music videos promoting sexual activity.

Overall, we cannot hope to optimize changes in adolescents’ sexual behavior without addressing the broad range of factors that influence adolescents’ decision-making process and, in turn, their likelihood of engaging in risky sexual behavior (24).


COnclusion
In order to achieve greater success, “It’s Your (Sex) Life” campaign must move beyond the traditional health behavior models- focused on individual level factors. Merely examining individual-level determinants in isolation provides a limited perspective on a complex issue and, furthermore, precludes a more in-depth understanding of how higher-level variables (e.g., family, peers, school, community, and society) may be independently associated with STD risk behaviors in the presence of other individual-level factors (19). Thus, while efficacious in promoting the adoption of STD/HIV-preventive behaviors in the near-term, individual-level interventions appear to be insufficient in sustaining newly adopted preventive behavior changes over protracted periods of time (19). What is needed is a complementary approach that addresses these multiple spheres of influence and adopts alternative health behavior change models capable of changing people’s behavior en masse to the desired or protective health behavior.

Section 2

To address the problem of rising STD’s rates among adolescents, I propose an intervention/strategy that promotes condom use at a group level by utilizing the following alternative health behavior models: marketing (social marketing) and framing theories.

Marketing is defined by the American Marketing Association as the activity, set of institutions, and processes for creating, communicating, delivering, and exchanging offerings that have value for customers, clients, partners, and society at large. Social marketing is the systematic application of marketing strategies along with other concepts and techniques to achieve specific behavioral goals for a social good. Social marketing seeks to influence social behaviors and to benefit the target audience, the general society and not the marketer.(26)
The defining features of social marketing emanate from marketing’s conceptual framework and includes exchange theory, audience segmentation, competition, “the marketing mix,” consumer orientation and continuous monitoring. (27)
Framing comes from cognitive science, which defines a frame as a conceptual structure involved with thinking.(28) Frames are a composition of elements—visuals, values, stereotypes, messengers— which together trigger an existing idea. Frames tell us what a communication message is about. They signal to us what to pay attention to (and what not to), and they set up a pattern of reasoning that influences decision. Framing, therefore, is a translation process between incoming information and the pictures in our heads (29)

Intervention: Ignite Campaign- bringing out the fire in you

This intervention builds on the growing evidence which indicate that promoting pleasure in condom use, alongside safer sex messaging, can increase the consistent use of condoms and the practice of safer sex.(30) Ignite campaign aims to reduce STD’s rate by increasing the consistent use of condoms among sexually active adolescents. It aims to achieve this by reframing the use of condoms as being pleasurable rather than a just a protection “tool” from sexually transmitted diseases; also by using effective marketing strategies to spread its’ message.

Components of the Intervention

1) Form partnership with a condom manufacturing company in order to make Ignite pleasure condoms.

2) Use strategic adverts to reframe condoms as being pleasurable. I created two commercials which use pleasurable activities (dancing, and going to the beach) to appeal to core values (such as attractiveness, pleasure, vitality, sex) which adolescents value more than health.


Commercial One:
Several teens are gathered in an arena to watch a Salsa dance competition (illustrated by showing contestants (adolescents) with their partners (male and female) wearing salsa dance costumes)
Scene: Presenter of the show: Let’s welcome our final contestants for the night
(The crowd cheers)
Two teams come on stage and as the salsa music plays both teams start dancing.
Team 2: The female partner suddenly stops dancing…..she tells her partner “I can’t continue dancing…..my wrist hurts severely”. Her partner smiles and brings out a pack of Ignite condom (she smiles), he opens the condom pack and ties it around her wrist. Immediately vibrant salsa music plays, team 2 does amazing dance steps and wins the competition. At the end of the commercial, Ignite condom- bringing out the fire in you is displayed.

Commercial two:
Four teenage boys sitting on the beach suddenly get excited when four attractive females walk up to them. The boys stare so hard that “fire” comes out of their eyes. Each of the girls show the boys a box of ignite condom…..strangely the boxes become “alive”, grow so big and each female enters the box. Happily each boy grasps one Ignite condom box.

The two commercials use the power of visual imagery to frame the message. Imagery in brand marketing helps to create the external ideal (e.g. a figure, image or symbol that embodies socially desirable characteristics). Thus an individual will aspire to close the gap between his or her own self image and the idealized external image (e.g. Ignite condom brands).

3) Spread the message via a multi-channel approach by using a combination of traditional media channels, including TV, radio, print (billboards, celebrity, sports and other youth magazines), and new media such as internet websites (blogs, download materials, videos, games, celebrity and Ignites’ own website), E-mail services, Social networks (Facebook, Myspace), Youtube, Desktop agents, mobile phone texting and placing ads on other hand held computing devices.

4) Organize community based events such as concerts, cultural festivals, fairs where free Ignite condoms can be distributed. Distribution can be extended to recreational centers, school health centers, summer camps, hair salons etc. Flyers that have the logo of Ignite and the picture of the star couple in the Salsa dance ad will be distributed. Also, members of the community will be engaged in advocacy for the provision of sufficient resources (e.g. comprehensive adolescent health centers) for adolescent health.

5) Regular evaluation of the campaign to gauge the responses of the target audience to all aspects of the intervention, from the broad marketing strategy to specific messages and materials.

Argument: Why the Ignite campaign is better than It’s Your (Sex) Life campaign
1.) Strength of the alternative health theories over the health belief model
Unlike the HBM that relies completely on individual level factors to change behavior, the alternative health models utilize the group phenomenon to change people’s behaviors en masse. Groups are not just a collection of individuals; they have certain characteristics which individuals tend to adopt. For example, though an adolescent may not want to engage in risky sexual behaviors, when he/she perceives that friends and similar-aged teens engage in risky sexual behavior, then he/she is more likely to adopt those same behaviors (19). The alternative health theories do not focus on predicting individual behavior rather they take advantage of the predictable group “mentality” (the herd mentality) to change an entire group at the same time. The Ignite campaign uses effectively two alternate health theories (Framing and Marketing) which have been proven to yield desirable results in the commercial and political sector. There is substantial evidence that social marketing is effective in changing health behaviors on a population level (31). The VERB campaign, It’s what you do, promoted by the CDC is a good example of how social marketing can change health behavior at a group level. Marketing alters the environment to make the recommended health behavior more advantageous than the unhealthy behavior it is designed to replace (27).

The Ignite campaign uses the framing theory to appeal to other core values (sex, attractiveness, pleasure) more compelling to adolescents than health as used by the IYSL and other public health campaigns. Framing an issue on core values more important to individuals (level 1) is vital because they are the ones that connect to individuals in the deepest way (29) which can trigger the ‘jolt’ necessary for instantaneous behavior change. According to Lakoff (1996), people’s support or rejection of an issue will largely be determined by whether they can identify and connect with the Level 1 values rather than the minute details of issues (e.g. statistics of sexually transmitted diseases) which may “crowd’ level 1 core values and make the campaign message ineffective. The national Truth campaign used the framing theory to appeal to the rebellious core value of adolescents. By successfully framing non-smoking as being rebellious and promoting a teen focused “counter marketing” brand, Truth campaign was able to account for 22 percent of the decline in adolescent smoking prevalence from 25.3% to 18.0% from 200-2002. (32)



2.) Self control
Unlike the IYSL campaign which assumes that adolescents have self control over their actions and can take charge of their sex life, the Ignite campaign takes cognizance of the fact that people have difficulty with self control and their social reasoning is influenced not only by their basic intellectual abilities, but by their desires, motives and interests (12). In addition, the alternative health models used in the Ignite campaign take advantage of the fact that human behavior is influenced by expectations, predictably irrational and not planned. For example, there are “seasons” in the stock market when investors (skilled and unskilled) “rush” to buy a particular stock at unreasonable high prices because such companies have strategically raised the expectations of consumers (via branding, framing and marketing theories) and taken advantage of the predictable irrational “herd” mentality. Similarly, by successfully associating the Ignite condom brands with the core values (sex, attractiveness and pleasure) that appeal to adolescents, the Ignite campaign can take advantage of adolescents lack of self control (which contributes to risky behaviors) and predictable irrational behavior in order to increase the use of Ignite condoms. Trust campaign, conducted by the U.S.-based Population Services International (PSI) promoted an HIV/AIDS prevention social marketing campaign that was effective in reaching adolescents and young adults in Kenya. The Trust campaign promoted the social desirability of condom use by making condom use seem cool. Studies show that the campaign increased adolescents and young adult awareness of the Trust condom brand and increased condom use among those with repeated exposure to the brand. (33)

It is important to note that while the commercial marketing strategies benefit the marketer, the social marketing strategy used by Ignite campaign benefits the target audience and the society at large by reducing STD rates and its consequences. In addition, by actually making pleasurable condom packs, Ignite campaign is not deceiving the target audience.

3.) Social Determinants



Though the Ignite campaign may not be able to address all the societal factors that influence adolescents’ behaviors, it offers a more comprehensive approach for addressing these factors than the IYSL campaign. Firstly, because adolescents are increasingly less subject to parental influence and more subject to peer and media influence (31), there is a dire need for public health professionals to promote media campaigns that can influence adolescents. Campaigns that appeal to the core values of adolescents are more influential than campaigns which emphasize on the negative consequences of acquiring STD’s. The use of negative messaging (“don’t do this behavior”) counters the rebellious core value of adolescents. Adolescents rebel against external restrictions on their independence and self-control (31), thus they develop opposing reactions to negative — “don’t do it” —messages. For example adolescent boys who associate displeasure strongly with condom use are likely to rebel against outside forces who try to “impose” condom use on them without offering them an immediate, tangible, gratifying and valuable exchange that will not make them feel a loss. Thus by reframing condom use as pleasurable and using ads that do not counter the rebellious nature of adolescents and appeals to their other core values (pleasure, attractiveness, sex), the Ignite campaign has superiority in using the media to influence adolescents’ behaviors than the IYSL campaign. The success of the Trust campaign in increasing condom use by framing condom use as being cool, illustrates the power of branded messages that convey positive behavioral alternatives for young people (33).

Secondly, through the extensive use of multi-channels by the Ignite campaign, the campaign is capable of fighting the “battle” against other media and marketing exposures that can promote risky health behaviors. The VERB campaign, It’s what you do, is an excellent example of a public health campaign that used several multi channels to reach its target population. The VERB advertising and promotions reached “tweens” in their homes, schools, and in their communities. The primary vehicle was paid advertising in the general market and in ethnic media channels. The VERB made use of TV, radio channels, print advertising in dozens of youth publications, websites, social networks (Facebook, MySpace) and other media agents such as text messages. Evaluation of the VERB campaign showed that as these same children became more aware of VERB, they engaged in more free-time physical activity sessions. The average 9-to 10-year old youth who were aware of VERB engaged in 34 percent more free-time physical activity sessions per week than did 9- to 10-year-old youths who were unaware of the campaign. (31)

Thirdly, the Ignite campaign also offers a comprehensive approach to promoting preventive behaviors through its outreach to the communities and school based centers. In addition, by involving community members in advocacy for provision of comprehensive adolescent centers, the Ignite campaign takes advantage of the “power” of social marketing in affecting policy makers through the media to frame public debate in support of enacting health policies; thus by influencing policy makers, they can address the broader social and environmental determinants of health (27).

Conclusion
The alternative health behavior models (Framing and Social Marketing Theories) used by the Ignite campaign have the potential to promote preventive sexual behaviors among adolescents; and thus reduce STD rates. Public health professionals need to abandon the “myth” that using such strategies to promote healthy behaviors is manipulative and unethical. It is time for public health campaigns/interventions to look beyond the traditional health models which have failed to curb STD rates among adolescents. The Ignite campaign provides a strong model that can be used to win the war against sexually transmitted diseases.

REFERENCES
1.) Music television channel (MTV).IT’S YOUR SEX LIFE. http://itsyoursexlife.com/iysl
2.) Johnson E. H, Gant L, Hinkle Y. A., Gilbert D, Willis C, Hoopwood T. Do African American men and women differ in their knowledge about AIDS, attitudes about condoms and sexual behaviors? Journal of National Medical Association.1992; 84(1):49-64.
3.) DiClemente R. J, Forrest K. A, Mickler S. College students’ knowledge and attitudes about AIDS and changes in HIV-preventive behaviors. AIDS Education and Prevention. 1990; 2(3): 201-212
4.) Lollis C. M, Johnson E. H, Antoni M. H.The efficacy of the Health Belief Model for predicting condom usage and risky sexual practices in university students. AIDS Education and Prevention. 1997; 9(6): 551-563.
Sands T, Archer J, Puleo S. Prevention of health-risk behaviors inn college students: Evaluating seven variables. Journal of College Student Development. 1998; 39(4): 331-342. Steers W. N, Elliott E, Nemiro J, Ditman D, Oskamp S. Health beliefs as predictors of HIV-preventive behavior and ethnic differences in prediction. Journal of Social Psychology. 1996; 136(1): 99-110.
5.) Evelyn B. Winfield and Arthur L. Whaley A Comprehensive Test of the Health Belief Model in the Prediction of Condom Use Among African American College Students. Journal of Black Psychology. 2002; 28(4):330-346
6.) Kyung-Hee Choi; Gust A. Yep; Eugene K. HIV Prevention Among Asian and Pacific Islander American Men Who Have Sex with Men: A Critical Review of Theoretical Models and Directions for Future Research. AIDS Education and Prevention. 1998; 10(A): 19-30.
7.) Mary K. Salazar MN, COHN. Comparison of four behavioral theories. AAOHN Journal. 1991; 39(3):128-135.
8.) Eisenberg N, Morris A. Moral cognitions and pro-social responding in adolescence (pp. 155–188). In: Lerner R. and Steinberg L ed. Handbook of Adolescent Psychology. Wiley, 2004
9.) Sobesky W. The effects of situational factors on moral judgments. Child Dev. 1983;
54:575–58
10.) Klaczynski P.A. Bias in adolescents’ everyday reasoning and its relationships with intellectual ability, personal theories, and self serving motivation. Dev. Psychol. 1997; 33:273–283
11.) Klaczynski P, Gordon D. Everyday statistical reasoning during adolescence and young adulthood: Motivational, general ability, and developmental influences. Child Dev. 1996; 67: 2873–2891
12.) Laurence Steinberg. Cognitive and affective development in adolescence. Trends in Cognitive Sciences. 2005; 9(2 ):69-74
13.) Benthin A. Adolescent health-threatening and health enhancing behaviors: A study of word association and imagery. J. Adolesc. Health. 1995; 17:143–152
14.) Cauffman, E. and Steinberg, L.The cognitive and affective influences on adolescent decision-making. Temple Law Rev. 1995; 68:1763–1789
15.) Slovic, P. What does it mean to know a cumulative risk? Adolescent’s perceptions of short-term and long-term consequences of smoking. J. Behav. Decis. Making. 2000; 13:259-266
16.) Steinberg, L. Risk-taking in adolescence: What changes, and why? Ann. N. Y. Acad. Sci. 2004; 1021: 51–58
17.) Blanton H, Gerrard M. Effect of sexual motivation on men’s risk perception for sexually transmitted disease there must be 50 ways to justify a lover. Health Psychology. 1997; 16:374–37
18.) Dan Ariely, George Loewenstein. The Heat of the Moment: The Effect of Sexual Arousal on Sexual Decision Making. Journal of Behavioral Decision Making. 2006; 19: 87–98
19.) DiClemente R.J, PhD, Salazar L.F, PhD, Crosby R.A, PhD. A Review of STD/HIV Preventive Interventions for Adolescents: Sustaining Effects Using an Ecological Approach. Journal of Pediatric Psychology. 2007; 32(8):888-906
20.) Hogben M, PHD, Leichliter J.S, PHD. Social Determinants and Sexually Transmitted Disease Disparities. Sexually Transmitted Diseases. 2008; 35(12):S13–S18.
21.) Upchurch D.M, Mason W.M, Kusunoki.Y, Johnson M. Social and Behavioral Determinants of Self-Reported STD Among Adolescents. Perspectives on Sexual and Reproductive Health.2004;36 (6):276–287
22.) Teitler JO and Weiss CC. Effects of neighborhood and school environments on transitions to first sexual intercourse. Sociology of Education. 2000; 73(2):112–132
23.) Wingood GM, DiClemente RJ, Bernhardt JM, Harrington K, Davies SL, Robillard A. A prospective study of exposure to rap music videos and African American female adolescents’ health. American Journal of Public Health. 2003; 93(3):437–439
24.) Wingood GM, DiClemente RJ, Harrington K, Davies S, Hook EW. Exposure to X-rated movies and adolescents’ sexual and contraceptive-related attitudes and behaviors. Pediatrics. 2001; 107(5):1116–1119
25.) Maton K. Making a difference: The social ecology of social transformation. American Journal of Community Psychology .2000; 28(1):25–57
26.) Kotler P, Andreasen A. Strategic Marketing for Nonprofit Organizations.
New York: Prentice Hall, 1996.
27.) Grier S, Bryant A.C. Social marketing in public health. Annu. Rev. Public Health. 2005; 26:319–39
28.) Lakoff, G. Don’t Think of an Elephant! Know Your Values and Frame the Debate. Chelsea Green: White River Junction, 2004
29.) Dorfman L, Wallack L, Woodruff K. More than a message: Framing public health advocacy to change corporate practices. Health Education & Behavior. 2005 ; 32 (3): 320-336
30.) Philpott A, Knerr W, Boydell V. Pleasure and Prevention: When Good Sex Is Safer Sex. Reproductive Health Matters. 2006; 14(28):23–31
31.) National Institute for health care management. Recommended Adolescent Health Care Utilization: How Social Marketing Can Help. NIHCM Foundation Issue Brief March 2009.
http://www.nihcm.org/pdf/NIHCM-SocialMarketing-FINAL.pdf
32.) Farrelly MC, Davis KC, Haviland ML, Messeri P and Healton CG. Evidence of a Dose-Response Relationship Between ‘truth’ Antismoking Ads and Youth Smoking. American Journal of Public Health. 2005; 95(3):425–431.
33.) Agha S. The Impact of a Mass Media Campaign on Personal Risk Perception, Perceived Self-Efficacy and on Other Behavioral Predictors. Aids Care. 2003; 15(6):749–62

Labels: , , , ,

Monday, May 11, 2009

The Get Talking, Get Tested Campaign: A Social Sciences Critique and Recommended Improvements – Dana Greeson

HIV/AIDS has been a highly stigmatized illness since the epidemic began in the United States in the early 1980s. The “4 H’s” referred to the groups who were most associated and often blamed for the spread of the virus: homosexuals, heroin addicts, Haitians, and hemophiliacs (1). HIV has had a devastating impact on these groups and each has reacted in different ways. In recent years, with the advent of antiretroviral treatment, HIV has shifted from a death sentence to a chronic disease in high-income countries. The Office of HIV/AIDS within the Massachusetts Department of Public Health provides services such as prevention, education, counseling, testing, client services and health and support services (2). The MDPH emphasizes multicultural health and recognizes that minorities and those living in poverty face a high burden of HIV/AIDS (2). The Get Talking, Get Tested campaign through the MDPH encourages African Americans and other black residents in Massachusetts to get HIV testing and talk about it with their loved ones (3). While this campaign targets one of the highest-risk populations in the state, the message is too narrow, with certain key issues ignored. In this paper I will use principles from the social and behavioral sciences to critique the Get Talking, Get Testing Campaign (GTGTC) and present ways to improve the campaign based on these principles.

Get Talking, Get Tested

According to MDPH Commissioner John Auerbach, "this campaign encourages people to get tested, not just for their own sake, but for the sake of their family and for their community as a whole. We want people to know that testing is fast, free and confidential, and to understand that getting tested for HIV should be a regular part of their health care routine" (3).

Campaign posters state “HIV testing is fast, free and confidential.” There are three styles of posters: one with two black men, another with a black man and a black woman and a third with two black women (see Annex 1). The relationships between the pairs are ambiguous. For example, the poster with the two women can be perceived as two friends, sisters, a mother and daughter, or partners.

Why Focus on the Black Population

The African American and black populations in Massachusetts carry an inequitable burden of HIV/AIDS compared to other race ethnicities. Data from the MDPH show that 50% of recently diagnosed women and 25% of recently diagnosed men are black non-Hispanic (4). Among those living with HIV/AIDS, 41% of women and 23% of men are black (4). Aside from race, country of origin also plays a role in the HIV/AIDS disparity. From 2004 through 2006, 44% of women and 22% of men diagnosed with HIV were born outside of the U.S. (4). Different populations differ in their modes of exposure to HIV/AIDS and therefore require separate interventions. For example, drug use is the primary exposure for white women where as heterosexual sex is the primary exposure for black women (4).

The Biopsychosocial Model of Health

The first social science approach that I will use to critique the Get Talking, Get Tested campaign is the Biopsychosocial Model created by Dr. George Engel in 1977 (see Annex 2). Dr. Engel was a psychiatrist who sought to address the shortcomings of the biomedical model of health. He recognized that the gap between the fields of medicine and psychology was negatively affecting patients. Dr. Engel stated that health and disease were strongly influenced by society, culture, and psychology and that providing patients with quality care required practitioners to look beyond biology and physiology (5).

Although there are effective testing and treatment methods for HIV/AIDS that fit within the biological circle of the Biopsychosocial Model, the sociological and psychological circles require more attention. Within the U.S., there has been substantial HIV/AIDS social marketing that promotes prevention and testing. Although these campaigns have aimed to reduce HIV/AIDS stigma, it remains deeply embedded in many cultures. In this sense Positive Deviance (PD) may be an effective approach in targeting specific cultures and communities and enhancing the sociological circle of this campaign. PD is a behavior change approach based on the idea that community problems have existing solutions within the community (6). This approach takes advantage of existing community resources and solutions and often leads to more practical interventions than those that come from outside of the community (6). Using Positive Deviance to decrease HIV/AIDS stigma could work by presenting respected HIV positive community members, who are leading productive lives, to the specific cultural groups of which they are members (these people are referred to as “positive deviants”). For example, if gender inequity was an issue within a culture, a campaign could show a well-respected man in the community supporting his wife or girlfriend getting tested. This could effectively reduce stigma and decrease gender barriers to testing.

The Lazarus Effect is a phenomenon that can also be used to reduce HIV/AIDS related stigma. This refers to the idea that antiretroviral drugs (ARVs) can transform a person from nearly dead to relatively healthy and could also be applied the sociological circle of this campaign (see Annex 3). This effect received its name from the bible, where Jesus raises Lazarus from the dead, which is essentially what ARVs are doing for people living with HIV/AIDS. The Lazarus effect is perhaps the most effective type of social marketing for community members as it provides proof of the efficacy of ARVs and the benefits of being tested and taking appropriate medications. Positive Deviance and the Lazarus effect are some examples of how the sociological circle can be improved.

The psychological circle of the Biopsychosocial Model should be addressed through culturally appropriate counseling and support groups. Although the Office of HIV/AIDS provides counseling, the Get Talking, Get Tested Campaign does not mention counseling in its advertisements. This information should be more explicit for target populations. Studies have shown that fear and avoidance play a large role in why many people go unscreened for a variety of illnesses (7). Counseling has been one effective method of addressing these fears (8).

The Political Economy Approach

Although HIV was originally associated with homosexual men, prevalence among women has been steadily increasing in Massachusetts (4). As discussed above, incidence in women is higher within cultures and communities where women are marginalized. Risk factors for women are related to socioeconomic status, country of origin, religion, education level and power differentials within romantic relationships.

Political Economy provides a macro level approach to understanding and addressing these types of disparities in health. There are three key components to the Political Economy approach. The first step is to think of a health issue as the result of certain societal interactions such as those mentioned above (class, gender, etc.) (9). Next, this approach looks at health issues as being part of a trajectory of risk, which is influenced by relationship patterns in society (9). The Political Economy approach states that public health interventions must address societal relationships that contribute to the issue (9).

The Get Talking, Get Tested campaign addresses societal components of HIV/AIDS, but not some of the most important ones. The campaign recognizes that HIV/AIDS prevalence is higher for black residents than white residents in Massachusetts. Black residents make up six percent of the Massachusetts population, but account for 28 percent of residents with HIV/AIDS (3). They are 11 more likely to have HIV/AIDS than white residents (3). The campaign has been effective at targeting black communities through health care centers and advertisements in the Massachusetts cities with the highest incidence of HIV among black residents (32-61%: Boston, Springfield, Worcester, Lynn and Brockton) (3) (10).

While it is extremely important that the black community receive targeted HIV/AIDS messages, it is also important that gender inequality is addressed. Gender inequality is a relationship pattern that can contribute to a trajectory of risk for HIV/AIDS within and outside of the black community. Some of the highest-risk residents in Massachusetts are immigrant and refugee women who do not speak English, have low levels of education, are uninsured, and face substantial gender inequality within their relationships (4)

In a recent lecture, Dr. Nicole Prudent, a Haitian physician at Boston Medical Center, discussed some of the societal obstacles for young Haitian immigrant women related to HIV. She explained that Haitian women are valued most in their roles as wives and mothers (11). Many of these women have already experienced trauma when they arrive in the U.S. They have difficulty finding jobs and gaining financial independence and are unsure how to access health care. If they are in a relationship, they probably lack decision-making power. If they are not in a relationship, they are likely feeling pressure from their families. These women also come from a culture in which HIV has been highly stigmatized. Dr. Prudent explained this scenario so that we could understand all of the factors that might prohibit young Haitian women from getting tested for HIV. These women are already feeling completely overwhelmed and the possibility of being diagnosed with HIV is terrifying. If a married Haitian woman is diagnosed with HIV her husband may abuse her and/or leave her. If a single woman is diagnosed she is unlikely to fulfill the valued role of wife and mother and may be shunned by her family. While Dr. Prudent agreed that testing is absolutely necessary, she explained that it cannot be the first step in a HIV campaign. Although this example is about Haitian women, it is generalizable to other marginalized groups who are already struggling with an overwhelming amount of issues and cannot imagine facing one more challenge.

The GTGTC does not mention anything beyond the test itself. What kind of support will be provided for those who test positive? Are there examples of people from similarly marginalized groups who are better off for being tested? What kinds of treatment barriers exist for undocumented persons with HIV? These are important societal questions that would be addressed in the Political Economy Approach.

The Communications Theory

The Communications Theory is based on the communication process where the goal is for the message receiver to interpret and act based on the message (9). The first thing to consider when disseminating public health messages is whether the target population can relate to the messenger. The messenger must encode the message to have the optimal effect on the population. A major communications challenge with HIV/AIDS campaigns is that high-risk people speak a variety of languages and literacy rates are sometimes low. The GTGTC has only printed materials in English. This is a major flaw in the campaign. In the Haitian community, a respected Haitian woman, such as Dr. Prudent, might be the ideal messenger since she shares a cultural background with the target population. The GTGTC could distribute materials in various other languages depending on the venue and target population. Of course, this still leaves the issue of illiteracy in ones native language, which can be addressed through other channels such as the health radio program that Dr. Prudent does in French Creole. Another ideal channel within the Haitian community is church since the population is almost exclusively Catholic and attendance is high. This may prevent many women who cannot read from missing out on important information.

Improving the Get Talking, Get Tested Campaign

In this section of the paper I will explore improvements that can be made to the Get Talking Get Tested Campaign by applying the three social science models previously discussed. The goal of these improvements is to better reach high-risk subgroups within African American and other black communities in Massachusetts.

Improvements based on the Biopsychosocial Model of Health

I explained earlier how the GTGTC falls short of meeting the Biopsychosocial Model of Health and how other approaches, such as Positive Deviance, may be more effective in addressing the sociological and psychological circles within the model. Positive Deviance looks to solutions already present within a community and relies on respected community members to disseminate health messages. Several ideas that I will present in this section can also be applied to the Communications Theory.

Kalichman and Coley designed a study to test the idea that people are more receptive to messages delivered by someone who they perceive as similar. Factors that one may have in common with the messenger are age, race, sex, ethnicity, religion, education level and socioeconomic status. They randomly assigned 100 black women in a health clinic to watch one of three videos on HIV testing. The narrator in the first video was an African American man. An African American woman narrated the second and third videos, but the third video also included culturally relevant consequences of not getting tested such as not living long enough to raise ones children (12). Results showed that the women rated the narrator in the third video as being significantly more concerned about them, their families and their communities. Of the women who watched the third video and stated intention to be tested within two weeks, 63% followed up compared to 23% who watched the second video and none who watched the first video (12).

Although the GTGTC did not use video as a communication channel, an issue I will discuss below, I would recommend that the MDPH partner with trusted organizations within the black and immigrant communities of Massachusetts. Berlo and colleagues state that trustworthiness and expertise are the most important factors that one considers in determining whether a source is credible (13). Currently, the only emblem on GTGTC material is the one for the Massachusetts Department of Public Health. Since the state government runs the DPH, there may be issues of trust for undocumented immigrants, and black people in general, who have a history of being mistreated by the government and medical institutions. If these subgroups see that trustworthy organizations are partnered with the Department of Public Health on the HIV testing initiative they will likely be more apt to get tested, just like the women in the Kalichman and Coley study. The Multicultural AIDS Coalition, run through the African Health Initiative Boston, is an example of an organization that works specifically with the immigrant and black populations and is therefore likely to be perceived as more trustworthy.

Levy and colleagues studied the reasons for delayed HIV presentation among immigrants and found that it was associated with a lack of knowledge, secrecy, stigma and symptom specific health seeking behavior (14). Undocumented immigrants who avoid testing due to fear of deportation would likely be more apt to get tested if they could identify a trustworthy organization in partnership with the campaign. At the very least, they could seek guidance and have their concerns addressed by the organization. The Lazarus Effect could also be incorporated into campaign materials to demonstrate that diagnosis can lead to better health and quality of life. While source credibility, Positive Deviance and the Lazarus Effect address the sociological circle of the Biopsychosocial Model, the campaign should also communicate the availability of appropriate counseling services and supports to address the psychological circle.

Improvements based on the Political Economy Approach

The subgroups of the population that are most negatively affected by HIV/AIDS mirror many of the subgroups that are vulnerable to poor health outcomes in general. According to the Political Economy approach, interventions must consider various societal interactions, such as class and gender, which may put people at increased risk of various health outcomes. (9). One of the most concerning factors is that the relative risk of HIV infection is 11 for blacks compared to whites. This disparity is exacerbated among women of color who make up 83% of new HIV diagnoses among women in Massachusetts (2). People of color living with HIV/AIDS also face increased mortality compared to whites with the virus. Another trend is for immigrants to be diagnosed much later than those born in the U.S. A significantly higher percentage of immigrants are diagnosed with AIDS within two months of their HIV diagnosis (36% versus 25%) (2). These statistics show the importance of targeting not only the black population as a whole, but also immigrants and women within it.

The Political Economy approach is another example where a positive deviant within a community can set a good example. In this case, a respected male can encourage other men to respect the women in their lives, both in general and in regard to health. Similarly, respected black men can encourage their peers to come together and get tested in an effort to decrease stigma and the spread of HIV within the black community. A positive deviant woman or a group of women can strategize safe and realistic ways of gaining power and respect within their relationships, families and communities. Since contracting HIV is often a product of marginalization, increasing women’s self efficacy and power, which is certainly easier in theory than practice, should serve to decrease their vulnerability to contracting the virus and delayed testing. Campaigns that promote HIV testing, must emphasize and provide adequate support both pre and post-testing. The more marginalized a person is who is being tested, the more severe consequences s/he may face upon testing positive.

Improvements based on the Communications Theory

Since I have already addressed the importance of perceived similarity, trustworthiness and expertise in health messengers, I will focus on the channel and language components of the Communications Theory. The GTGTC material is only presented on billboards and other printed media, which may be missing the most vulnerable subgroup: immigrant women of color who do not read English. Instead, I propose that airing short commercials on specific television channels watched by these populations would be more effective in reaching this target audience. Women from the various subgroups should be consulted for their ideas and opinions throughout the creation of these commercials. Research is needed to determine the channels and times of television viewing among specific population subgroups. Next, several versions of the commercial would be piloted among subgroups to ensure cultural and linguistic appropriateness. This channel of communication would reach those who cannot read English or do not commute to work and are therefore less likely than their male counterparts to see advertisements on buses and billboards. Other communication channels to consider are beauty parlors, churches and antenatal clinics depending on the specific subgroup.

Conclusion

While the Get Talking, Get Tested campaign is off to a good start in that it targets high-risk populations, it does not delve deeply enough into the trauma associated with HIV testing and the cultural barriers that may inhibit someone from being tested. Applying the Biopsychosocial Model of Health to this campaign emphasizes the need for some cultures to have more positive examples of people they can relate to who have been tested and/or are HIV positive and leading productive and meaningful lives. Culturally appropriate counseling and support groups may help with the avoidant behavior associated with testing. The Political Economy approach encourages campaigns to look at the big picture in order to understand the societal barriers that people face in seeking health care. Finally, the Communications Theory stresses the importance of using appropriate messengers, language and channels in disseminating public health messages. Applying these three social science theories to the Get Talking, Get Tested Campaign could help it to impact the most vulnerable members of society through increased HIV testing and use of comprehensive HIV/AIDS services.


References

(1) Gallo RC. A reflection on HIV/AIDS research after 25 years.. Retrovirology 2006, 3:72 2006 10/20/06;3(72).

(2) Massachusetts Department of Public Health HIV/AIDS Bureau. An Added Burden: The Impact of the HIV/AIDS Epidemic on Communities of Color in Massachusetts. World AIDS Day December 1, 2007. 2007 12/1/07:1-14.

(3) Health and Human Services. Get Talking, Get Tested. DPH Office of HIV/AIDS Expands Awareness Campaign. 2009; Available at: http://www.mass.gov/?pageID=eohhs2pressrelease&L=1&L0=Home&sid=Eeohhs2&b=pressrelease&f=090203_get_talking_tested&csid=Eeohhs2. Accessed 4/2, 2009.

(4) Massachusetts Department of Public Health. Massachusetts HIV/AIDS Data Fact Sheet. Women at Risk of HIV Infection. 2008 6/08:1-3.

(5) Engel G. The Need for a New Medical Model: A Challenge for Biomedicine. Science, New Series 1977 4/8/77;196(4286):129-136.

(6) Sternin M, Sternin J, Marsh D. Designing a Community-Based Nutrition Program Using the Hearth Model and the Positive Deviance Approach - A Field Guide. 1998 12/98:1-85.

(7) Vermunda SH, Wilson CM. Barriers to HIV testing-where next? The Lancet 2002 10/19/02;360(9341):1186-1187.

(8) Irwin KL, Valdiserri RO, Holmberg SD. The acceptability of voluntary HIV antibody testing in the United States: a decade of lessons learned. AIDS 1996 12/96;10(14):1707-1717.

(9) Edberg M. Essentials of Health Behavior. Social and Behavioral Theory in Public Health. Sudbury, Massachusetts: Jones and Bartlett Publishers; 2007.

(10) Goodhue T. Executive Office of Health and Human Services Department of Public Health, Memo. 2008 6/6/08:1.

(11) Prudent N. 2009 4/2/09;Lecture.

(12) Kalichman S, Coley B. Context framing to enhance HIV-antibody-testing messages targeted to African American women. Health Psychol. 1995;14:247-254.

(13) Berlo D, Lemert J, Mertz R. Dimensions for evaluating the acceptability of message source. Public Opin. 1969;33:563-576.

(14) Levy V, Prentiss D, Balmas G, Chen S, Israelski D, Katzenstein D, et al. Factors in the Delayed HIV Presentation of Immigrants in Northern California: Implications for Voluntary Counseling and Testing Programs. J Immigrant Health 2007;9:49-54.

Labels: , , , ,

Thursday, May 7, 2009

Not Just About Cervical Cancer, Not Just About White Women-Nora McElroy

Awareness about HPV, or human papilloma virus, has dramatically increased in the last five years as a result of several educational and pharmaceutical industry driven campaigns.  The result has been increased awareness of the release of a vaccine that protects against several varieties of HPV and bolstered efforts to inform women of HPV and its carcinogenic effects.  Various public service announcements specifically intended to educate women about the existence of HPV and its association with cervical cancer were aired before the release of Merck’s vaccine Gardasil.  The design of these campaigns has missed a significant portion of people affected by HPV: men, the poor, and minorities. 

            Human Papilloma Virus is the most common sexually transmitted disease in the United States (1).  At any given time 44% of women have HPV and over 70% will contract the virus at some point in their lifetime (2).  HPV is also responsible for 5.2% of the total world cancer burden, making it a significant source of cancer diagnosis and mortality (3).  It is clearly associated with a potentially terminal disease, but also can cause uncomfortable genital warts in both sexes and that may require surgical removal in women.  Though these campaign was designed separately, all have used the health belief model’s focus on negative outcomes, and therefore have all the weaknesses of the model (4).  The targets of ads, choice of outcome, and incomplete information does not educate the entire affected population and does not address barriers to prevention and screening of HPV.

            Though the media, women’s groups, and pharmaceutical marketing have been focusing on the causal association between HPV and cervical cancer the virus actually has several other health outcomes.  The most common symptom of HPV is genital warts, which can manifest in men and women (5).  If the lesions form on the cervix they are either frozen off or surgically excised.  Otherwise there is no treatment and the warts and virus eventually resolve on their own.  Unlike genital herpes, another genital wart causing disease, there is no treatment for HPV and the virus can be transmitted even if the infected man or woman currently has no warts (6).  There is also research linking HPV infection to oral cancers, but its carcinogenic link to cervical cancer is far better established (7).  Human papilloma virus is not just a women’s disease and interventions need to address equality of burden of responsibility and outcomes.

            Some of the earliest educational campaigns to spread awareness of the association between HPV and cervical cancer were television public service announcement campaigns.  They used the Health Belief Method, connecting HPV with a serious health outcome, to influence behavior.  “Tell Someone” was specifically targeted at women and encouraged them to tell their friends, family, and acquaintances that HPV caused cervical cancer.  The commercial also stressed that many women are already infected with and unaware of the virus(8).  Another PSA, for Maketheconnection.org, similarly stressed the causal association between HPV and cervical cancer (9).  Finally when Merck released its HPV vaccine, Gardasil, it launched a massive marketing and educational campaigned called “One Less.”.  It encouraged young, white, active women to be one less person affected by cervical cancer by speaking to their doctor and getting vaccinated (10).  This also lacked insight into the women most affected by HPV infection and cervical cancer.  Poor and minority women carry more of the disease burden than Caucasians and may not have access or a trusting relationship with a physician who could provide them with more information, screening, and vaccination (11).

            The PSAs take the wrong approach to HPV awareness, prevention, and screening.  All three PSA fail to mention that HPV is a sexually transmitted disease and that both men and women are infected and susceptible to genital warts.  Each targets only women, though men and women are equally likely to contract and spread the virus.  Also black, Latina , poor, and rural women are more likely to be infected with HPV and develop terminal cervical cancer, and yet these PSAs target healthy, middle class, usually white women (12).  Finally the chosen outcome, cervical cancer, is so distant that logically young women are not likely to consider it a risk when having sex.  The creators of these PSAs expect women, often teenagers, to consider a very distant outcome and do not offer any acknowledgement or assistance with the barriers of access, trust, or discomfort of discussing sexually transmitted diseases.

 

Not Just a Women’s Disease, HPV as a Sexually Transmitted Disease

 

            A major flaw in all of the PSAs is that they do not address the transmission dynamics of HPV.  After viewing any of them, a woman would have high perceived susceptibility to the virus without any concept of how she was exposed.  Since it is possible to contract HPV multiple times it is important that everyone, men and women, understand it is sexually transmitted.  It is not constructive to convince women they may have a life threatening disease by providing incomplete or misleading information.  This only results in fear and confusion, which makes further education and maintaining trust difficult.  By framing their intervention this way the advertisers actually construct more barriers by raising fear and requiring that people find the time and resources to get their own answers.  Omitting that HPV is a sexually transmitted disease places all the responsibility for screening and prevention solely on women by ignoring half of the infected population.

            Though cervical cancer is a specifically women’s disease human papilloma virus is not.  In targeting all of the commercials at women and the mechanism of transmission the marketers miss half of the people infected with and responsible for transmitting the disease.  Information on the disease burden of HPV in men is not nearly as available as women and men are not routinely screened.  Despite the relatively minor consequences for men there is no reason not to educate them about HPV, since it can cause genital warts and no person wants responsibility for causing cancer. 

            Still the framing of these interventions of HPV as a women’s disease, and not as a sexually transmitted disease, limits its potential and does not address the gross disparity of responsibility placed on individual women.  In order to prevent HPV related symptoms and diseases the target of interventions cannot be just women.  Placing all of the responsibility on women is undue burden, and does not address infections in men.

 

“Ask Your Doctor”

Disparities in Disease Burden, Knowledge, Trust, and Access

 

            The campaigns repeatedly encourage women to speak to their doctors about the risks and ways to prevent HPV infection, however many women do not have access to or trust a physician.  The commercials primarily feature well-dressed white women, ignoring that more of the disease burden of HPV is shouldered by Latino and black women.  Geography and lack of trust are known predictors for not seeing a doctor regularly, either because of access, cost, or mistrust (14).  Despite a great deal of research showing higher proportions of HPV in poor, rural, and minority areas the interventions do not target any of these populations.

            Disease burden and lack of HPV awareness are more common in black and Latina women when compared to Caucasians (15).  However both the “Tell Someone” and “Make the Connection” campaigns predominantly feature white and middle class women and do not use any branding or social theory to engage the viewer.  As a result women who most need the information will not relate to the commercial and therefore not benefit from it.  The “One Less” commercials fare slightly better by showing younger women of various races participating in activities like skateboarding, double-dutch, and step, which would connect better with the audience.  However the advertisement also informs women that they need to talk to their doctor for more information about HPV, cervical cancer, and the HPV vaccine.  The women targeted are the most likely to not have regular medical care or trust a doctor enough to discuss sexually transmitted diseases.

            The topic of STDs can be very difficult to discuss without a great deal of trust and cultural/societal sensitivity (11).  By presuming that viewers have a regular physician, much less be able to discuss sexual behavior with them, these campaigns lose touch with many poor, rural, young and minority women who do not.  Not enough information is given about other ways for these women to learn about HPV or affordable screening.  Offering an information source where the caller remains anonymous or providing contacts for free local clinics might be a better approach to engage poor and minority women.

 

Cancer in Twenty Years, Or Sex Now?  The Reaction of Teens and Parents

 

            Aside from the lack of insight into the women affected by HPV these campaigns also choose to focus on a distant and very rare outcome of infection.  Though approximately 70% of cervical cancer is caused by human papilloma virus it takes about fifteen years and persistent infection with specific strains of the virus for cancer to form (2).  This is a very rare outcome and is not likely to sway young people from having sex, or convince them to use protection.  Even vaccination is not an option for many young women due to the high cost of Gardasil.  The HPV vaccine costs about one hundred and fifty dollars for the three shots that grant immunity to four strains of the HPV virus (16).  However this is not complete protection against cervical cancer because vaccines are not 100% effective and Gardasil only protects against the two most common carcinogenic strains of HPV (17).  Therefore women who have had the vaccine are at reduced risk for cervical cancer, but are not immune.

            The “One Less” Campaign also targets mothers, which perhaps is a more effective strategy than targeting teenagers.  Mothers are more susceptible because they want their children to have a long and healthy life, and therefore have an interest in protecting their daughters from HPV and cervical cancer.  However using cervical cancer as the focus of the campaign creates more fear than necessary since it is such a rare outcome.  Cervical cancer is a real and dangerous disease, but if regular screening and testing is made widely available, accessible, and affordable, it is curable.  Therefore it is unnecessary to scare parents about what might happen to their children.  Providing enough information, like how HPV is transmitted and prevented is responsible, would be more effective because it would allow parents to inform their children about the risks.

             Finally the campaign ignores certain aspects of the disease that are more immediate concern and would help build a better case for people to defend themselves against it.  The genital warts that are sometimes caused by human papilloma virus are very uncomfortable, and in women can require minor surgery to remove (18).  Though these symptoms could be difficult to discuss with a doctor and are only treated when present on the cervix they could be used to encourage men and women to use protection and be screened regularly for HPV.  Persistent genital warts are a high risk factor for cervical cancer.  Therefore an intervention that ties together the carcinogenic potential of HPV and the more immediate discomfort of genital warts could be more effective.

 

Conclusion

 

            Due to the serious nature of cervical cancer it is easy to see why it has been a major motivation for HPV education.  However these interventions must be carefully framed so more people get the message than upper and middle class white women.  While these women may be more likely to be screened or afford vaccination others are at equal or higher risk of infection.   These interventions also unfairly put all of the responsibility for prevention and screening on women, for a disease that is carried by both sexes.  How can a virus be contained when only half of the population is being told about it?  In order to effectively reduce HPV infections and increase screening these interventions need to be redesigned to provide more useful information and reach a much larger segment of viewers.

 

 

Using Social Marketing to Raise Awareness of HPV

 

            The past approaches have relied too heavily on the health belief model and tried to raise awareness by focusing on a very distant outcome.  A major problem with the health belief model is that it targets individuals, not groups of people (14).  However research shows that people tend to consider social opinions and norms when making decisions as well (15).  Instead of using an antiquated model that has been shown to be ineffective, the social sciences have other concepts that are effective at educating and changing behavior.  Though the first two campaigns were based entirely on the health belief model, the “One Less” campaign begins to blend behavioral science with the health belief model.  The slogan “One Less” is a form of branding, which is a component of marketing theory.  Social marketing is an excellent way to reach a large audience, and account for social norms and opinions.  Four major components are required for an effective social marketing intervention: product, price, place, and promotion (16).  Using these four components an initiative that addresses the weaknesses of the previous interventions can be created.

            As has already been discussed, place and product have been poorly targeted in HPV education campaigns, having focused on white women with more access to physicians, instead of the populations most at risk.  They also ignored that men are also carriers and transmitters of the disease, a key fact in slowing the spread of HPV and its other associated cancers (17).  A new television advertisement using marketing theory can fill these holes, educating men and women about the immediate and distant effects of HPV, while offering help to those without resources for prevention or screening.   The product offered will be confidence from being informed, placed on television screens, which is a common part of the lives of most American teens, and promoted by high circulation during shows popular with teenagers.  It will also address the price by offering free information and access to HPV and cervical cancer screening.

            The new commercial opens with two black teenagers cuddled in front of a television.  In a warm colored room two black teenagers lean against a wall, the boy says: “You’re cool, you know how it works, and you’re in charge.  So why do people want you to think that only women need to think about HPV?  Human papilloma virus is sexually transmitted: that means both men and women get it.”  The young woman adds: “Don’t think just because you don’t have cervical cancer, or a cervix that, you don’t need the facts.  HPV causes genital warts in men and women, as well as several cancers, don’t sweat it, be smart.”  Meanwhile images of teenagers in classrooms and walking down an urban street flash across the screen.  The young man: “Take charge, condom use, vaccination, and abstinence all can reduce the spread of HPV.  And all HPV related cancers are treatable with regular screening.”  Finally the young woman concludes: “Knowledge is power, take control, get informed, get tested for HPV, and get tested for cervical cancer.  Call this number for more information and free, confidential testing and treatment for HPV, genital warts, and HPV related cancers.”

 

Bringing Men into the Equation

 

            A glaring omission in earlier interventions has been that HPV is a sexually transmitted disease carried by both men and women.  The new intervention intentionally features a young man and woman to counter the perception that only women need to worry about HPV.  A key part of marketing theory is offering an aspirational image to the consumer (18).  Both teenagers in the new commercial are confident, relatable, and informed, encouraging viewers to be like them and get informed.  Building on the knowledge disseminated in the other widely distributed commercials, it explains that HPV also causes genital warts.  Providing simple education greatly increases awareness of HPV risks and outcomes among young adults (19).  A simple change in the old method, including men and women in the commercials, broadens the audience.

            This demonstrates several improvements over the other commercials.  Men would have had no interest in the earlier commercials, since they stressed the link to cervical cancer.  Though men may worry about cancer in their wives or children, a young man is not likely to consider cancer an outcome when having sex and likely needs a more personal risk to consider changing behavior.  Gender based research shows that men and women may require different approaches to some public health issues (20).   Additionally, the intervention appeals to young men and women’s desire for self-dependence and independence. By implying that being informed and protecting themselves and others against HPV makes you in charge and in-the-know, youth are sold the image of a strong and mature self.

 

Reaching Out to High Risk and Uninsured Populations

 

            Another key component of the product offered in the new intervention is featuring young people of color, particularly black, so the intervention reaches the people most likely to contract HPV.  Despite starring black students the commercial could target more people since the actors are the same age as the students at risk for their first HPV infection.  Again the image of confident, independent teens offers an ideal that viewers can achieve by using the information offered (18).  The new intervention also makes information, treatment and screening more available by offering a number to call, instead of informing viewers to speak to their doctors.  It promises confidential and affordable options, which hopefully would encourage people without health insurance or routine doctors visits to call.  Addressing the price of seeking information and screening is vitally important because the populations most in need of aid are poor, without insurance or regular health screenings (21).

            Both of these are improvements over the older commercials.  By offering a strong identity to youth the campaign attracts attention and sidesteps any stigma around talking about or getting tested for a sexually transmitted disease.  And, unlike the other interventions, the psychological and monetary cost of HPV screening is acknowledged.  Offering a toll free number allows young people to get more information without needing to see or trust a doctor.  Also the commercial stresses confidentiality and free screenings, these are necessary for the success of the intervention (22).  Doctor’s appointments and vaccinations are very expensive and not affordable for portion of the US population.  Free screening, discounted vaccinations, and aid in finding affordable treatment help control the costs, unlike the other commercials which provided no information of making screening and preventative measure accessible.

 

Not Everyone has a Cervix, But No One Wants Genital Warts!

 

            Genital warts are an outcome that which it far more likely to attract male attention than cervical cancer because it is a symptoms they can have themselves.  As the young women said: men don’t have cervixes, why should they care?  By providing an outcome that is relevant to the entire population that carries the disease the commercial will reach a more homogenized audience (23).  In women these warts can require surgical removal and there is no treatment for men except to wait for them to resolve, and have a far shorter latency period than cervical cancer (21).  Providing this information to young men and women may encourage them to choose safer practices like using condoms.  Since the intervention is targeted at a susceptible population it will also encourage them to learn more about HPV and give access to screening and treatment.  It’s important in this intervention to attract attention with the product of being informed and prepared, but also educate so the audience understands why preventing HPV infection is important.

            Many social and behavioral intervention models, such as the health belief model, involve a weighing of the perceived risks against various social and physical barriers against change (24).  Raising awareness for a different outcome of HPV infection the new intervention stresses another, more immanent result.  All the earlier interventions repeatedly stressed a cervical cancer which takes 15 or more years after infection with HPV to become detectable.  Twenty years is a very long time in the future for a teenager to consider when having sex (25).  Other STDs that affect more people, like HIV, herpes, or Chlamydia attract more attention because of their unpleasant or lethal outcomes that come shortly after infection or are chronic once contracted.  By choosing a more immediate outcome of HPV the new intervention improves the chances that teens may consider taking actions to prevent infection or gets screened for HPV and related cancers.

 

Conclusion

 

            The intervention outlined above addresses a number of the weaknesses of common HPV awareness and prevention campaigns.  By integrating social marketing concepts and building on the awareness that the other commercials spread.  The inclusion of men, and low income, uninsured blacks ensure that the education campaign will reach more people.  In addition the new intervention offers help getting and paying for screening for HPV related diseases, another measure to reduce the vulnerability of marginalized population to HPV.  Finally the new commercial stresses that genital herpes is an outcome of HPV infection, a more immediate outcome for women and relevant one for men.  The combination of these changes make the new intervention better at reaching the people that most need education about the risks of HPV.

 

References

 

1.  Wright JD, Herzog TJ."Human papillomavirus: emerging trends in detection and management." Curr Womens Health Rep. 2002 Aug;2(4):259-65.

 

2.  Trottier, Helen; Franco, Eduardo L.  Human Papillomavirus and Cervical Cancer: Burden of Illness and Basis for Prevention.  American Journal of Managed Care December 2006; 12: S462-S472.

3.  Parkin, DM.  The global health burden of infection-associated cancers in the year 2002.  International Journal of Cancer 2006 Jun 15; 118(12):3030-44.

4.  Rosenstock IM, Strecher VJ, Becker MH.  Social learning theory and the Health Belief Model.  Health Education Quarterly Summer 1988; 15(2):175-83.

5.  Handisurya A, Schellenbacher C, Kirnbauer R.  Diseases caused by human papillomaviruses (HPV).  Journal of the German Society of Dermatology 2009 Mar 4; pre-publication e-release.

6.  Gravitt PE, Jamshidi R.  Diagnosis and management of oncogenic cervical human papillomavirus infection.  Infectious disease clinics of North America 2005 Jun; 19(2):439-58.

7.  Herrero R, Castellsague X, Pawlita M, et al.  Human Papillomavirus  and oral cancer: the International Agency for Research on Cancer multicenter study.  Journal of the National Cancer Institute 2003; 95: 1772-1783.

8.  “Tell Someone.”  Youtube.  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4yV7SpHOcrw

9.  “Make the Connection.”  Youtube.  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OMbvhug7CGU&NR=1

10. “One Less.”  Youtube.  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hJ8x3KR75fA&feature=related

11.  Clark PA.  Prejudice and the medical profession: a five-year update.  The Journal of law, medicine & ethics : a journal of the American Society of Law, Medicine & Ethics 2009 Spring; 37(1):118-33.

12.  Watson M, Saraiya M, et al.  Burden of cervical cancer in the United States, 1998-2003.  Cancer 2008 Nov 15;113(10 Suppl):2855-64.

13.  Schiffman M, Wacholder S.  From India to the World — A Better Way to Prevent Cervical Cancer.  The New England Journal of Medicine 2009 Apr 2; Volume 360:1453-1455.

14.  Maticka-Tyndale.  Sexual Scripts and AIDS Prevention: Variations in Adherence to Safer-Sex Guidelines by Heterosexual Adolescents. The Journal of Sex Research February, 1991; Vol. 28, No. 1: 45-66.

15.  Ajzen, I.  The Theory of planned behavior.  Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes.  1991; 50: 179-211.

16.  Edberg, Mark.  (2007).  Essentials of Health Behavior: Social and Behavioral Theory in Public Health.  Boston: Jones and Bartlett Publishers.

17.  Agrawal, Y.  Oral Human Papillomavirus Infection Before and After Treatment for Human Papillomavirus 16–Positive and Human Papillomavirus 16–Negative Head and Neck Squamous Cell Carcinoma.  Clinical Cancer Research.  November 1 2008; 14: 7143.

18.  Mailbach, Edward W.  A Marketing Perspective on Disseminating Evidence-based Approaches to Disease Prevention and Health Promotion.  Preventing Chronic Disease: Public Health Research, Practice, and Policy.  Volume 3, no 3 July 2006.

19.  Lambert, E.  College Students’ Knowledge of Human Papillomavirus and Effectiveness of a Brief Educational Intervention.  The Journal of the American Board of Family Practice May-June 2001; 14: 3, 178-183.

 

20.  Correa-de-Araujo, R.  Serious Gaps: How the Lack of Sex/Gender-Based Research Impairs Health.  Journal of Women's Health. December 2006, 15(10): 1116-1122.

 

21.  Ho GY, Studentsov Y, Hall CB, et al. Risk factors for subsequent cervicovaginal human papillomavirus (HPV) infection and the protective role of antibodies to HPV-16 virus-like particles. Journal of Infectious Diseases. 2002;186(6):737–742.

 

22.  Ghosh AK, Jana S.  Role of service staff of STD clinics in targeted intervention programmes for SWs and other marginal communities.  International Conference on AIDS 2000 Jul 9-14; 13.

 

23.  Slater Michael, Flora J.  Health Lifestyles: Audience Segmentation Analysis for Public Health Interventions.  Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the International Communication Association (39th, San Francisco, CA, May 25-29, 1989). Retrieved from http://www.eric.ed.gov/ERICDocs/data/ericdocs2sql/content_storage_01/0000019b/80/1f/87/83.pdf on 4/30/2009.

 

24.  Becker, MH et al.  The health belief model and personal health behavior.  The Health Education Monograph 1974; 2: Entire Issue.

 

25.  McDermott-Webster, M.  The HPV Epidemic: a common STD can progress to cervical cancer.  The American Journal of Nursing (Mar., 1999). Vol. 99, No. 3;  24L-24N.

Labels: , ,